Oh Claire you are so right.
Sorry but I dont agree she is right.
First, I moved up from London to Birmingham in 1979 and worked near Five Ways roundabout. I used to walk down Broad St some lunch times and it was a dump. I have photographs I took of Broad St in the early 1980s and it was terrible,
Secondly, she mentions "unaffordable" flats but many of the flats in these apartment blocks are sold BEFORE the building is finished. Some of these apartment blocks have hundreds of flats, but in many cases they are all sold before completion. So hardly unaffordable.
Sadly I think too many people remember the city centre through rose tinted spectacles.
Since I moved here in 1979 the city has improved totally.
Back then we had a AWFUL BullRing, an AWFUL New St station, the area where Brindley Place is (just off Broad St) was full of awful small factories, the canals were dirty and unused with few people walking around them, and we had lots of horrible pedestrian underpasses full of vomit and grafitti.
I used to walk round the canals near Broad St on a Sunday in the 1980s taking photos and could walk for 2 or 3 hours and not see a SINGLE person. Now I go up there and I see HUNDREDS of people:- working, attending conferences, eating, drinking, enjoying themselves.
The city is a 100 times better than it was when I moved here in 1979.
There is still a lot to do (the huge Wholesale Market needs to be demolished and the area redeveloped) and other areas need improvement, but it is a long slow process that can take decades.
But the city is certainly a lot better than it was 40 years ago.