Thanks that's really useful. He may not have registered it. It may have been Nellie, my Nan, his daughter. When her mother died she had to take over and be mum to her little sister Florence & when she married, James & Florence came to live with her. He had a teensy bit of a drink problem and so did Sarah by all accounts! Poor little Nellie had a bit of a life. So if I contact Birmingham registry office hopefully they can check whether it was James or Nellie. Thanks so much for your help. This particular part of the family intrigues me because of the Jewish connection because obviously they would have, at some point, come from Europe or Russia. I'm still working on Sarah's birth. On the 1891 census it says she was born in Dudley Warwickshire & on the 1901 census it says she was born in Worcester Worcestershire. I've found a birth record for a Sarah Ann Amos in 1867 in West Bromwich. The date sounds about right but I'm not sure whether West Bromwich would be the same as Dudley or Worcester. If you have any thoughts on that, I'd be grateful. I've also found a Sarah Ann Amos on 1871 Census for Wednesbury born around 1860 but I have my doubts about that one. I've also found an Eleanor S Amos on 1881 Birmingham census born in Dudley, Staffs around 1866. The reason I have saved this record is because Nellie, my Nan's name was really Eleanor & her mother may have used her 2nd name Sarah as people do. Her grandaughter thought she was Sarah Ann but she may have been wrong about that. But I can't find a birth record for Eleanor S. Sorry if this is a bit confusing.