• Welcome to this forum . We are a worldwide group with a common interest in Birmingham and its history. While here, please follow a few simple rules. We ask that you respect other members, thank those who have helped you and please keep your contributions on-topic with the thread.

    We do hope you enjoy your visit. BHF Admin Team

Birmingham Nightclubs of the Past - Memories

  • Thread starter Thread starter mazbeth
  • Start date Start date
that photo looks odd to me pen the 2 signs above where it say erdington meat co looks french or the letters are all mixed up..then look at the 2 adverts below where it says carlton ballroom..they dont look english..and what about the adverts in the windows of brooks bros and dale forty they dont make any sense to me also look at the lettering underneath where it says carlton ballroom ltd (was it really called that) they also dont make sense to me...i think this photo could have been messed around with

lyn
I agree Lyn it looks like an AI enhanced image
 
At first im thought it was just a blurry photo that had been sharpened by AI. However, unless there were two photos taken at the same time, with the same car in place and with two spidery figures and a bicycle at the corner of the butchers, then it has definitely been falsified . AI thinks it looks better with it;s additions. Original less sharp photo below.

Erdington High Street,C.1963-64.jpg
 
At first im thought it was just a blurry photo that had been sharpened by AI. However, unless there were two photos taken at the same time, with the same car in place and with two spidery figures and a bicycle at the corner of the butchers, then it has definitely been falsified . AI thinks it looks better with it;s additions. Original less sharp photo below.

View attachment 233287
Well I can live with that for more than an AI restoration job, at least this looks authentic
 
At first im thought it was just a blurry photo that had been sharpened by AI. However, unless there were two photos taken at the same time, with the same car in place and with two spidery figures and a bicycle at the corner of the butchers, then it has definitely been falsified . AI thinks it looks better with it;s additions. Original less sharp photo below.

View attachment 233287
also if we look at mikes original photo i can now see that the notice above reads in english fred something and son...as time goes by history is going to be thrown out of the window by AI and not just affecting old photos but the written word as well..from now on i will certainly be looking even more closely at the old photos..

lyn
 
In view of the outraged comments made above, that have just come to light, about my post #2488, I feel I should offer an explanation.

1. My intention was to show a clear image of the Mothers Nightclub, in which I happen to be interested.
2. The original online newspaper image (to which I gave a full link) was of poor quality:

1795106475965.png
So I thought I would quickly clarify it and used Google "nano2 banana" to do so.

3. I was pleased with the immediate result. I didn't notice that the sign above the Meat supplier was now AI gobbledegook (but then it was incomprehensible in the original). I entirely failed to notice the two pedestrians and a parked bicycle which had been added next to the "Erdington Meat Co", not only because they were unasked for but also because their images are slight and convincingly incorporated into the whole:

1795106609255.png

4. So I was happy to post the image of Mothers Nightclub, highlighting what was required i.e. the actual premises.

5. My main mistake was to have asked the AI engine to "enhance" the original image. That instruction seems to have given it license to adjust things artistically too. I should have been much more specific by requesting something such as "Please sharpen this newspaper image but make no additions". This highlights the fact that AI will do as it is instructed but may add aspects that it's algorithms consider "helpful" unless the instructions are absolutely specific. The result also needs to be carefully checked for accuracy.

6. It is correct to state that if AI is used it should be declared. I thought it had just clarified and sharpened the photographic image in this case like a good graphics program but more or less instantly and so nothing else was necessary. As it turned out, however, I was mistaken because subtle additions had been made which I inadvertently overlooked and I apologise for that.
____________________________________________________​

PS Whilst on the subject of additions to images, the statement in #2493 that the "original less sharp photo" is shown there seems odd because in this version an "XYZ" (see red arrow) appears by the corner of the parked car and is unexplained and absent from the actual, toned (not grayscale) original which is shown above. Perhaps it was taken from another source.

1795106783816.png
​
 
Last edited:
In view of the outraged comments made above, that have just come to light, about my post #2488, I feel I should offer an explanation.

1. My intention was to show a clear image of the Mothers Nightclub, in which I happen to be interested.
2. The original online newspaper image (to which I gave a full link) was of poor quality:

View attachment 233633
So I thought I would quickly clarify it and used Google "nano2 banana" to do so.

3. I was pleased with the immediate result. I didn't notice that the sign above the Meat supplier was now AI gobbledegook (but then it was incomprehensible in the original). I entirely failed to notice the two pedestrians and a parked bicycle which had been added next to the "Erdington Meat Co", not only because they were unasked for but also because their images are slight and convincingly incorporated into the whole:

View attachment 233635

4. So I was happy to post the image of Mothers Nightclub, highlighting what was required i.e. the actual premises.

5. My main mistake was to have asked the AI engine to "enhance" the original image. That instruction seems to have given it license to adjust things artistically too. I should have been much more specific by requesting something such as "Please sharpen this newspaper image but make no additions". This highlights the fact that AI will do as it is instructed but may add aspects that it's algorithms consider "helpful" unless the instructions are absolutely specific. The result also needs to be carefully checked for accuracy.

6. It is correct to state that if AI is used it should be declared. I thought it had just clarified and sharpened the photographic image in this case like a good graphics program and so nothing else was necessary. As it turned out, however, I was mistaken because subtle additions had been made which I inadvertently overlooked and I apologise for that.
____________________________________________________​

PS Whilst on the subject of additions to images, the statement in #2493 that the "original less sharp photo" is shown there seems odd because in this version an "XYZ" (see red arrow) appears by the corner of the parked car and is unexplained and absent from the actual, toned (not grayscale) original (which is shown above). Perhaps it was taken from another source.

View attachment 233637
​
Hi Neil

Thanks for explaining, and please don’t apologise. Nobody was angry. It just showed we needed some clear guidance, and we’d been meaning to write it for a while. Your point about “enhance” is really useful, and other members will learn from it. We’d love you to keep posting. On the “XYZ” by the car in #2493, It has me puzzled too, does anyone know where that version came from?
 
Back
Top