• Welcome to this forum . We are a worldwide group with a common interest in Birmingham and its history. While here, please follow a few simple rules. We ask that you respect other members, thank those who have helped you and please keep your contributions on-topic with the thread.

    We do hope you enjoy your visit. BHF Admin Team

Shepherd's Pie

  • Thread starter Thread starter Beryl M
  • Start date Start date
B

Beryl M

Guest
Shepherd's Pie is confusing on two counts, first it is not truly a pie, there being no pastry involved and secondly a lot of people mistake it for cottage pie (it is Shepherd's Pie if made with lamb or mutton and Cottage Pie if made with beef.

Traditional Shepherd's Pie can be bland and dull so we will be zapping this up with a few additions to the basic "school dinners" recipe.

Now, as Mrs. Beeton might have said, "first catch your shepherd..."

Ingredients (to serve 6 to 8)

2 lbs. Potatoes (mashed with a little milk or butter)
1 medium onion
2 carrots
1 stick celery
1 to 1½ lbs. minced (ground?) lamb or mutton
a small clove of garlic
2 tablespoons (2 Ounces) tomato puree
equal amount of water
Salt, Black Pepper to taste
½ teaspoon each, Thyme & Cumin
A shake of Worcestershire or Soy sauce.

Heat your oven to 200 Celsius, 400 Fahrenheit

Peel, the potatoes and set them boiling. There will be plenty of time to prepare the rest prepare before they are ready to mash.

Mince or finely chop the onion, carrot and celery and gently fry them in a little of your favourite oil or fat.

Once the onion is translucent set the vegetables aside and fry the lamb with the garlic until it is brown (traditional British chefs would recommend not doing this, but if you don’t the meat will look grey and unappetising.)

When the meat is browned stir the tomato puree and Worcester / Soy sauce into the water and add it to the lamb.

Add the thyme, cumin, salt and pepper and return the vegetables to the pan.

About now the potatoes should be ready to mash with the milk and butter.

Let the meat simmer while you do that.

Put the meat and vegetables in an oval baking dish (it doesn’t have to be oval, but somehow it looks better) Now lightly spread the mashed potatoes on top and fork the surface into a "ploughed field" pattern (kids of all ages like it like that) and bake at the top of the oven for 30 minutes.

British cooking has a reputation for blandness. It was not always so - before the Protestant reformation enjoying one’s food was not considered sinful. Do not skip on frying the vegetables and meat here, it improves the flavour immensely and follows the method described in Elizabethan cookery

To make Cottage Pie simply substitute beef for lamb.
 
Shame I've already had dinner. It sounds delicious! I love garlic with lamb. Try stuffing several cloves inside the lamb whilst roasting. The smell is lovely. All depends on taste though
Lynda
 
I have some hamburger in the fridge and I am going to make this tomorow.
Just have to check for the tomato puree.
If I am not back blame Beryl.....or congratulate her...whatever.
 
Hi Beryl
Whats The Differents , If It Is Made With Lamb Mince , OR Mutton
Mince, Or Beef Mince , All Thrown In With The Pototoes
Carrots , Onions ,
Cottage Pie Is All Classed The Same ,
Surely The Word Pie Is Only A Figure Of Speech , ? .
Because We Make It In The Tray Like Mking A Cake ,
Either way I Just Like My Cottage Pie ,Anyway It Comes
I Could Eat It Until The Cows Come Home , YUM, YUM ,
Next Time I Have Cottage Pie ,
I Will Try ALF,S Specialality With The Grated Cheese On Top
Sounds Very Nice ,
In Fact It Sounds That Tastie , I Will Make One Today
Have A Very Nice Day Every one And ALL ,
And Happy Cooking , BEST WISHES , ASTONIAN ;;;;;
 
Hi, I made this meal and in the interest of continuing development make the following observations. I might mention that I have been looking for a good Shepards/Cottage pie for my culinary list for some time; mindfull of product that I have had in the past and not being able to replicate. This one comes darn close though.

Firstly I used lean ground beef so that the cottage pie was aimed at. The ground beef had been in the freezer for some months but seemed to be in good shape ie. no freezer burn.

Secondly is Tomato Puree the same as Tomato Paste. I did not have any so I used left over spaghetti sauce, rather more than the quantities indicated which did not seem enough for the amount of ground beef.

The vagetables indicated were fine in quantity and method.

With the exception of the puree all other directions were adhered to.

After frying the ground beef (Olive oil was used) there was large amount of liquid fat in the pan so this was poured off before proceeding further.

Observations:
Oven time and temp was good. The potatoes were nicely browned and looked great.

The taste was OK but was a little over powered by the spices. Maybe the tomato puree would have helped here.

The texture of the meaty part was a little rough. It did not hold together and was a little dry even though more than the recomended moisture was added. Since there was left over product, re-heating dryed the pie further, but was still eaten. Should more moisture be added, or a gravy perhaps.

I hope these comments do not offend. I intend to try this again with the correct puree and fresh ground beef. I look forward to reading any pointers here before sallying forth on this one again.

On to 'Bolton Hot Pot'. By the way Beryl, the dialogue that went with the recipe was inspired. I did use the ploughed field forking.

Rupert.
 
Rupert tomato puree is the same as tomato paste - I can't think as to why it would be dry - As regards the spices - each to his own taste - But I do think the tomato paste would have made all the difference.
However I am glad you tried it - I think you will have better luck next time!
 
Back
Top