Amazing drawing Bob, where did you find that from?
I have scanned this from this month's Brummagem magazine with the permission of Carl.
There is a section of photo's by Stan Millington sent in by his sister in law. Stan was a wedding photographer but for pleasure he took photo's around Birmingham. Stan was born in 1909 and died in 1972. I thought it would be nice if we could put more information on this photo.
![]()
I originally posted this and despite tremendous efforts by everyone an exact location was never found. You are correct when you say new members may have some new information so resurrecting the post does no harm.View attachment 144275
It is possible that a new member may be able to shed some light on the Sunday School, even it is a long shot. I think Williamstreeter is right in suggesting that windows are the key, and can be used to discount some suggestions.
I think you actually have it. Very little doubt in my mind now
Grea, although the illustration posted by RobT is very nice, you could not be convinced by a drawing with all its artistic licence! I will post some pics with concrete evidence.I think you actually have it. Very little doubt in my mind now
Although the large number of what I call picture/caption books are produced with the right spirit, many errors crop up. Sometimes the person who gathers the images together will rush it out, more or better evidence comes to light after publication, the author drifts from their area of expertise and comments on an element of an image without proper research, or any number of reasons. The caption books are not generally proof-read. The main problem these days is that the errors get replicated on websites and forums and this further entrenches the flaw and often reinvents the truth. In this case, I wouldn't be too harsh on David Harvey as, even after a lot of investigation, some folks still thought it was the Spring Hill Library.I think that all of us who persevered with this thread in the past came to the belief - if halfheartedly - that it was the Wycliffe Church and not Springhill Library. I had hoped that David Harvey may have made a comment (I did send a PM to him) as he might have more details being as the photo concerned was taken from his book.
Engraving - Wycliffe Chapel, BirminghamRob's illustration is the best I've seen from the that angle showing both the Chapel and the Sunday School.
James Granger seems to have been a Bookseller and gets a mention at 65 Islington in 1850, moving to 40 in 1851. He disappears after about 1858.
There is a signature to the bottom left, anyone make it out?
View attachment 144289
This happened to me, I did a book of postcards of our village, being very careful only to name names when I knew it was right (verified on the postcard). In a picture of the station I had been told by a railway 'anorak' that the stock on the train was old LSWR and was stock that had been cascaded down from the London area to the west country after the 1923 railway reorganisation, which matched up with the date of the postcard. I received a letter advising me that what I had written was wrong, etc etc and that I should check my facts. I got my friend to send him the facts and we heard no more, although the book was proof read b an 'expert', just prior to publication I spotted three spelling mistakes in the final proof copyAlthough the large number of what I call picture/caption books are produced with the right spirit, many errors crop up. Sometimes the person who gathers the images together will rush it out, more or better evidence comes to light after publication, the author drifts from their area of expertise and comments on an element of an image without proper research, or any number of reasons. The caption books are not generally proof-read. The main problem these days is that the errors get replicated on websites and forums and this further entrenches the flaw and often reinvents the truth. In this case, I wouldn't be too harsh on David Harvey as, even after a lot of investigation, some folks still thought it was the Spring Hill Library.
Thank you so much, no doubt whatsoever in my mind all along and this is definitive proof. Have to concentrate on the aircraft mystery now or perhaps the car-park location that has just been posted.It was only this morning when I thought I would have a rummage into my stuff. To be honest, I am not sure what I have got at times! However, it turned out that I have a number of photographs of St. Luke's Road, mainly with an emphasis on public-houses of course. Anyway, I have, without doubt, solved this highly-engaging and long-running thread and I will now run through the points I raised this morning with the help of some images. Firstly, I have took the liberty of re-posting the original post at the top of the thread .....
View attachment 144301
The bus is going slightly downhill from the bus-stop. Here is another view of St. Luke's Road as it goes downhill towards the bend to connect with Belgrave Road .....
View attachment 144303
Next up, is the bus-stop looking from the junction of Bristol Street. Not the shelter is the same. Note also that the metal posts are in evidence and, furthermore, the cobbles in front of the bus-stop can be seen .....
View attachment 144304
Here are the keep-left signs on the junction of Bristol Street [which also featured traffic lights]. These were on the Sun Street side of the junction .....
View attachment 144305
The Baptist Chapel had eight pinnacles .....
View attachment 144306
The roofline of the Sunday School featured the two gables - one large, one small [almost dormer-like] ......
View attachment 144307
And finally, and here I feel a bit like Henry Fonda producing a switch-knife and sticking it in the table used by the "12 Angry Men," the building had three narrow windows with the stepped windows .....
View attachment 144309
Once again, my only sadness is that it will mean the end of this epic thread!!
I'm not doubting ...Blimey, I have gone on record as saying this is DEFINITELY WITHOUT QUESTION a photograph taken in St. Luke's Road but the doubters are still doubting!!