John,
A great story - it was your Dad's piano and I guess he tried to take it with him, but at least made sure no one else would! There's nothing wrong in playing the charts. I spent years getting my reading up to scratch when I was young. I would go to the library and come back with the maximum 6 volumes that you were allowed to take out at any one time, largely within my playing capability at the time. I would attempt to play straight through them just once. I would make mainly technical (fingering) mistakes and they were not that important if you were trying to improve your reading. The main thing is not to know what notes are coming at you!
Next day I would take them back and get six more. My reading really improved with backing cabaret in Bournemouth. Rarely did we get a rehearsal. The singer - Elaine Delmar & Lita Roza were a couple that I remember - would arrive, give you a pile of dots and that was it. If there was the odd bum note, that was the singer's problem - should have arranged a rehearsal, but I can't remember any time that it didn't go off OK, even if it might have been a bit hair-raising. The worst were bad hand-written copies, generally bits of a larger orchestral arrangement and we were only a quartet! Now there's all these notation programs that propduce the perfect printed copy. I have a couple myself, but I can still write quicker by hand even with my arthritis!
Jazz is a different kettle of fish and is something that develops with your playing. But there are still lots of good musicians that cannot improvise. I remember seeing Stephane Grapelli and Yehudi Menuhin together on something like Parkinson, and Menuhin, a very capable classical violinist, was struggling to improvise. Yet you had people such as Andre Previn who could do the lot, excellent composer, conductor, pianist (both classical & jazz). I loved that guy's performances whatever he did - always first class.
Opera is something that I enjoy too, especially Puccini or Verdi, but it's not everyone's cup of tea. I'll dig out an aria or two for this thread later on.
Lynn,
Glad you enjoyed it and thanks for the Emperor. More food for thought for this thread, but later!
Maurice
