• Welcome to this forum . We are a worldwide group with a common interest in Birmingham and its history. While here, please follow a few simple rules. We ask that you respect other members, thank those who have helped you and please keep your contributions on-topic with the thread.

    We do hope you enjoy your visit. BHF Admin Team

Pte Martin Nolan Royal Welsh Fusiliers

  • Thread starter Thread starter O.C.
  • Start date Start date
O

O.C.

Guest
The True story of 2576 Nolan M. Pte. 1st Battalion Royal Welsh Fusiliers

Martin Nolan was the ninth of eleven children born to Michael and Winifred Nolan nee Towey and the sixth son. He was born on 31st March 1868, at the family home at 42 Price Street in the District of St. Mary’s, Birmingham in the County of Warwick. His father at the time of his birth was doing quite well in a business that he had taken over, after the death of his father, also named Michael, a month earlier. The trade that both his father and late grandfather followed was that of a Marine Stores Dealer’s, a strange title in landlocked Birmingham.
They were dealing with the passing barges, providing anything the bargees wanted and the provisions, which they required. The business was located on the side of the Grand Union Canal, between Snow Hill Wharf and Corporation Wharf.
Martin did attend school, and could read and write, his mother could do neither.
After leaving school he found work, which was mainly ordinary labouring work, but he wanted adventure so decided he would join the Army. He first enlisted in the 3rd Battalion the Royal Warwickshire Regiment but he was not happy being posted just down the road. So when the opportunity arrived he transferred into The Royal Welsh Fusiliers, whose main depot was at Wrexham in Wales. On his enlistment paper it states that he had blue eyes and two scars, one above his left wrist and the other on his right cheek, his weight being 1221bs and his chest measurement was 33ins. The thought of the fresh air, the open fields and the countryside soon got into his veins after spending all his life in the city of Birmingham.
On 4th October 1889, he became 2576 Pte. M. Nolan and Sgt James Kelly of the King’s Royal Rifle Corps witnessed his signature that day.
Martin was stationed in Wales, which was to be his home for the next year. It was here that he advanced his knowledge in the art of being an infantryman. He left Wales on New Year Day 1891 for India, where he spent 5 years, returning home on 14th June 1896 rather fit and tanned. His stay back in Wales was only for 3 years before the1st Battalion RWF was off to South Africa, in October 1899.
Trouble had being brewing for a number of years from 1881 between the two Dutch Boer republics, the Transvaal and the Orange Free State and the English Crown over these territories. Kruger, the Transvaal president, believed that Britain must eventually champion their cause and that war with it could only be a matter of time. In mid October 1899, when the Boer ultimatum was presented, there was only a small British force of 14,750 widely dispersed over all South Africa compared to 50,000 Boers.
A day before the war began 10,000 more troops landed from India and by the end of December, over 70,000 British and Commonwealth troops were in South Africa making it the largest force assembled by Britain ever to be sent abroad.
The Commander in Chief of the British Army, Sir Redvers Buller and some of his sub-ordinates, men like Warren, Hart, Long, Methuen, and Gatacre made mistake after mistake on the field of battle, and all seemed to be lacking in basic common sense and lack of military knowledge. Their task was to relieve the besieged towns in Ladysmith, Mafeking and Kimberley and beat the armies of Transvaal and the Orange Free State. In trying to do this, they undermined Britain’s military reputation in the eyes of the World, and Buller ruined his own career, going down in history as Sir Reverse Buller.
Martin Nolan fought in the many battles under different generals; some of whom he thought were a complete waste of time. These generals were still fighting the Crimea all over again and the men were still using outdated tactics (which the Boers took full advantage of) making them sitting targets for the crack shots that the Boers were, and who fought a guerrilla campaign.
The chaotic shambles the war was becoming soon reached the shores of England.
Lord Roberts was sent out to take command, with Kitchener as his chief of staff and with their professionalism and common sense, they soon got on top of the situation. The war finished on May 2nd 1902.
The total cost in lives was very heavy, 5774 killed and 16,000 died of disease on the British side alone.
On Martin Nolan’s medal ribbons were the following campaign and battle clasps, Transvaal, The Relief of Ladysmith, Orange Free State, Tugela Heights and Cape Colony. He received the South Africa medal with Queen Victoria’s head upon it and with her death on January 22nd 1901 and the war still raging he received his other South Africa medal for 1901 /1902 with King Edward V11’s head.
On 27th February 1900, he was posted missing presumed killed after the engagement at Tugela but was later found on the field of battle wounded, all this is in his Military History Sheet.
The central mountain barrier, between the British and Ladysmith, was finally overcome to allow the British cavalry to push through to Ladysmith.
Martin left Africa on 12th November 1902 and arrived back home in Birmingham in December. It was at Snow Hill railway station that his troubles began. Those personnel who could de-train and go on leave from here, could do so.
But as this was Martin’s home, he got off the train to a rowdy reception; on the station platform were reporters who heard that a troop train was arriving.
As there had been many questions asked over the way the Boer War had been fought, reporters were eager for knowledge about the war to put in the daily newspapers
Even in the House of Commons, the matter of lack of battle knowledge and tactics used against the Boers was discussed, and people wanted answers.
Martin was one of many walking along the platform, kitbag slung over his shoulders and glad to be in his home town, but he could not resist, when one of the reporters asked what were his thoughts on all the controversy being bandied about by the Press and Parliament. Without thinking and being a Nolan he said, “The Generals should be like that Little Fat Queen Victoria, f---ing dead”.
He was overheard by one of the Military policemen who was on that platform and was immediately arrested and charged. Martin’s actions that day resulted in him facing a court-martial where he was found guilty to the charge that was brought against him, and being unfit to plead, insane was inserted on his discharge papers, Form 268, where his signature was required, the word lunatic was inserted. So ended his army career, and it came to an end on 13th January 1903, after being found Guilty but Insane.
The army placed 33 year old Private 2576 Martin Nolan of the Royal Welsh Fusiliers into the local Lunatic Asylum at Winson Green, Birmingham.
It did not matter that he had a good army record and that he had never been in trouble before, other than the normal day to day Company errors, he was in his own mind a good soldier.
On his Proceedings on Discharge papers for Conduct and Character all that was written, was one solitary word – FAIR, which in Army Terms was on a scale of Very Good, Good, Fair, Indifferent, Bad, and Very Bad.
The only trouble was that he spoke out too loudly and was overheard, although in later years he was to be proved right. Many of those generals were a waste of time and money.
He entered the asylum straight after his court-martial, where he was to remain until his death over fifty years later at the age of 85 on 22nd March 1953.
Searching through the Newspapers in the Birmingham Central Library I came upon an article from the Birmingham Daily Mail, dated November 25th 1902, I wonder if it would have changed the outcome if Martin Nolan had read it and been able to escape.
Part of the article is reproduced below

The Lunacy Laws – Need for Reform
The statement made yesterday by Dr. Whitecombe with reference to the escape of the man Rawlings from Winson Green Asylum has not unnaturally created considerable surprise.
Rawlings escaped from the asylum by clambering over the boundary wall, and was never recaptured. This was borne out by the medical superintendent, who explained that at the expiration of fourteen days an escaped lunatic could not be taken back in to the asylum unless a fresh order of detention was obtained. Hence as Rawlings escaped on September 1st he was, according to the strict letter of the law, discharged on September 15th, although he was as a matter of fact, not in the asylum to be formally discharged by the authorities. In the ordinary course of things a man having been certified to be a lunatic remains in the institution until he has been cured, and then is allowed out on the instructions of the medical authority. If he escapes he is considered - by a legal fiction – to have recovered his normal condition of mind simply because he happens to evade the asylum authorities or the police for a fortnight.
Lunacy Act of 1890

I wonder today, if any service personnel spoke his or her own mind, whether they had made a derogatory reference to the Royal household or not, would be handed such a sentence. I have spoken to his remaining second cousin. They all said that they had gone and visited him, while he was in Winson Green Hospital. By this time he was too institutionalized to care about anything. Consequently when his nieces visited him, all they can recall, is that every other word uttered from his mouth was a swear word which drew giggles.
After spending 13 years and 107 days in the Royal Welsh Fusiliers he spent the last 50 years of his life in a lunatic asylum until his death.
And so ends the story of Martin Nolan condemned for using the ‘F’ word, a word that is commonly used by most of today’s youth.
 
Fascinating tale and so well written. What a terrible way for a brave man to end his life. :(
 
Thanks for sharing that, a terrible miscarriage of justice on a long serving soldier
I've read of several cases in recent years where descendants have forced the authorities to look at old cases like these with a view to clearing the persons name
Has any of his descendants thought about this at all?
 
Jerry
I cut this article by half which I should not have done as I thought it a bit to long for the forum but I have his photo and other material
The whole case rested on the oath he took at the Time he enlisted which I will put up in a little while sadly the chap who told me about this is not in the best of health.
The Army refused to put this article  in their Regimental Magazine as the Queen is the patron of the Regiment and they did not want to offend her .......................................Words Fail me !
 
I think the way forward in a situation like that is to take it to the papers, either local or national, if you were to gather all the info into a "presentation" I'm pretty sure you could get one of the papers to take up the case, It's amazing how a bit of adverse publicity can concentrate peoples minds ;)
 
Langstraat
I have no intention of going down the road of justice as you cannot give justice to a dead man
His story now has been told and that was my main aim. I will fight any underdogs corner who cannot fight back.
 
Jerry, this is the medical certificate
CERTIFICATE OF PRIMARY MEDICAL EXAMANATION
I have examined the above named Recruit and find that he does not present any of the following, vix: - Scrofula; phthisis; impaired constitution; defective intelligence; defects of vision, voice or hearing; hernia; hemorrhoids; varicose veins beyond a limited extent; marked varicocele with unusually pendant testicle inveterate cutaneous disease; chronic ulcers; traces of corporal punishment, or evidence of having been marked with the letters D., or B.C.; contracted or deformed chest; abnormal curvature of the spine; or any other disease
or physical defect calculated to unfit him for duties of a soldier.
He can see at the required distance with either eye, his heart and lungs are healthy, he has the free use of his joints and limbs, and he declares he is not subject to fits of any description. I consider him fit for the army.
Signed by Approved Medical Officer


Below is what I think sealed Martin Nolan’s Fate
OATH TO BE TAKEN BY RECRUIT ON ATTESTATION
I, Martin Nolan do make oath, that I will be faithful and bear true Allegiance to Her Majesty, Her Heirs, and Successors, and that I will, as in duty bound, honestly and faithfully defend Her Majesty, Her Heirs and Successors, in Person, Crown and Dignity against all enemies, and will observe and obey all orders of Her Majesty, Her Heirs, and Successors, and of the Generals and Officers set over me, So help me God
Signed Martin Nolan Witness James Kelly Sergt. K.R.R.C.
Dated 4th October 1889


Jerry
When you have digested the following I will post a bit more with his photo
 
A point worth noting Sir Redvers Buller was once described as the best colonel in the British Army who won the Victoria Cross during the Zulu Wars for his bravery but when promoted he became the worst general, who could not think his way out of a paper bag. Once the hero of the Victorian soldier he was soon despised and ended up a laughing stock nicknamed Sir Reverse Buller
A classic example of a gifted soldier who was promoted beyond his capacity while having plenty of courage bought humiliation on his country and himself in the Second Boer War.

Martin Nolan's photo taken in 1898​
 
One of the most brilliant officers ever to pass through the Army Staff College with marks the highest ever recorded was another bumbling idiot that got a lot of his men killed by his sheer stupidity in Africa during the Boer war.
He was a well educated man who saw action in the China wars and the brightest spark in the British Army so were did at all start to go wrong for General Sir George Pomeroy Colley.
The British had just over 1700 troops in the Transvaal which Colley was told could contain any situation which developed
On 20th Dec 1880 a column of 264 soldiers was stopped by a Boer commander who had over 1000 men entrenched on the high ground on both sides of the British.
The Boer Commander asked the British to go back as they were vastly outnumbered
And gave them two minutes to make up their mind.
The British led by Lieutenant Colonel Anstruthers for some reason or other decided to fight if out within an hour or so 77 British soldiers were dead and over 100 wounded, that event took place at Bronker’s Spruit, the Boers skill with a rifle was astonishing and lessons should have been learnt from that event but not so.
In 1881 the British invaded the Transvaal with General Sir George Pomeroy Colley in control of 1,000 troops even though he knew he was outnumbered 2 to 1 against an enemy firmly entrenched on the high ground with some of the finest sharpshooters in the country.
At the battle of Laings Nek 480 troops were ordered to charge the hill with fixed bayonets and take it, only to find themselves exhausted before the reached the top to be finally cut to ribbons by the Boer sharpshooters who killed 160 men.
Did Colley learn for this tragic defeat? NO
Colley thought the Boers won because they had the high ground so in his great wisdom he led 500 soldiers on a march though the night to the top of Majuba Hill which overlooked the Boers position and what did the do went they reached the summit? they let the Boers know as if it was some sort of game by laughing and jeering at them till one was shot though the head by a Boer sharpshooter.
Colley was asked if the men should dig in which he replied “No” before going to take a nap.
1000 Boer marksmen set up a barrage of fire to keep the British heads down while 180 expert marksmen who were nearly all young farmhands some as you as 12 climbed the hill with their beloved rifles slung over their backs.
Colley was woken up and told what was happening but promptly went back to sleep again. The young Ian Hamilton (who led the ill-fated Gallipoli Campaign) was at his wits end trying to tell Colley of the danger to no avail.
Then the firestorm started on the British and they were cut down like ears of corn.
Colley jumped up trying to take command but was promptly shot through the head by a 12-year-old boy so it was later stated.
The Boers killed 93 men 133 were wounded 58 taken prisoner the rest had fled in panic
And what of the Boers?
1 Killed five wounded 
Did we learn?
Martin Nolan knew the answer
 
If my memory is right at the bottom of Mount Street Nechells there was a small park with a hill in the middle which we called Spion Cop which was another one of our disasters
Does anyone know why us kids knew it as Spion Cop ?
The hill from the Boer War
 
Hi Cromwell, this is fascinating stuff, keep it coming.
Although I've never been a student of military history I know enough to have realised that the ordinary soldier's life was considered unimportant by pretty well all their officers
And when the fighting was done it was the officers who got the glory and the enlisted men who got dead
There is a park, as you say, at the bottom of Mount Street, Kandor mentioned it some time ago in one of his posts, he's from that area so he might be able to shed some light on the "Kop" question
Interestingly, there's an absolutely magnificent and almost Godlike football team in my beloved Small Heath that goes by the name of Birmingham City
Well before they rebuilt St. Andrews one of the stands was called Spion Kop! ;)
 
Jerry
Spion Cop was a dreadful disaster I dont study football and would I be saying the wrong thing if I ask why is it called Spion Cop ? is it because of the hight of the stands?or something else as it was a terrible defeat for the British
 
I don't know the answer to that but tomorrow I'll email their website and maybe someone will come up with the answer.
Maybe it was named as a memorial to the fallen soldiers?
I'll let you know if I find out anything O0
 
Spion Kop caused consternation in Britain and nearly brought down the government. The cabinet was at a loss to work out what could have gone wrong. The decision was made to send out Lord Roberts and Lord Kitchener to take over as commander in chief and chief of staff in South Africa.
Spion Kop drove the final nail into the coffin of Buller’s reputation. With the end of the war Buller was dismissed from the army, a terrible end to a worthy life of service to the British Crown, in spite of his failings.
Picture shows
243 of the British dead in the trench on the peak of Spion Kop
 
Jerry
Why should a football team name something after a defeat ( I have a feeling you are going to get some stick from opposition teams)
 
Jerry,
I feel obliged now to tell you about one of the most infamous Boer War battles
Spion Kop
One of the most preposterously incompetent general to serve in the Boer War was the 59-year-old former Police Commissioner who was waiting to retire and who had failed to trap Jack Ripper, by the name of Sir Charles Warren
After the disastrous personal defeat at Colenso by Sir Redvers Buller was reinforced by a new division under Sir Charles Warren
I n the halls of wisdom Sir Charles Warren was promoted to Lieutenant General Commander of the British Forces and sent to the Cape in 1900.
During the crossing of the Tugela River defended by a band of 600 Boers, Warren spent 26 hours supervising the transfer of his personal baggage across the river during that time 6,000 Boers had moved in to position to block his advance West of Spion Kop.
Both Buller and Warren thought the isolated hill of Spion Kop was key to the whole situation and command the Boer Positions. Neither man knew the terrain and failed to have the area scouted so ordered the troops to occupy the top without any thought on what they would do after.
Warren selected General Talbot-Coke to lead the attack who said he had a bad leg so Warren replaced him with 55 year old General Woodgate who Buller said had two good legs but no brains.
And so the assault on Spion Kop began in thick fog which would have been comical if not so tragic, on reaching the top they discovered solid rock so they could not entrench and someone had left all the sandbags down below as well as the field telegraph unit to keep in touch with the main force and the machine guns never came up with the men.
Visibility began to improve and they were astonished to find they were not on a hill at all but on a plateau some distance from the actual peak and higher up on three better positions were the Boers. The British troops were trapped on a plateau no more the a quarter of a mile square and tying to entrench into rock were pitifully inadequate
And one by one the troops were massacred by the Boer sharpshooter.
Woodgate was killed
Nine hours later the war correspondent Winston Churchill tried to tell Warren his men were trapped who flew into a rage and had him arrested.
A soldier that survived said of the battle we had no plan, no machine guns, no entrenching tools food or even water and while we were dying Buller had 20,000 men down below.
In letters Buller wrote to his wife he blamed the disaster on Warren saying he was a Duffer who lost me a good chance
Was it not suprising to later find out that the Disaster at Sulva Bay Gallipolli was caused by another tired worn out Boer War veteran Lt - General Stomford who had been Bullers military secretary
We did not learn a thing from the Boer War about Generals who were living in another age
 
I read your comments about private nolan. I went to visit the sites mentioned a few years ago. It's six of one and half a dozen of the other when we try to rationalise what went on, hindesight is a wonderful thing.
These pictures show the Kop that they climbed and died on.
The Kop means vantage point and passed into the language when the survivers came home, thats why so many footbal grounds have a Kop
 
Cromwell,

That's why I sent the picture of the kop mountain, it's a vantage point. They set off to climb it during darkness but failed to appreciate the steepness it was daylight when they reached the plateau and were spotted quite easily and picked off
 
Jerry
I found a photo I had taken in the 1990 of the little park in Mount Street showing what we called Spion Kop in the 50's Nechells Gas works are on the right.So The Hill is still in the Recreation Ground
 
I must show that photo to our children. They used to climb the hill when they were taken to the park by my husband Brian's aunt and uncle. They christenend it Grippy Shoes Mountain. :)
 
Is that park picture with the slide in Nechells? Near St Matthews School? - It looks very like a park I played in on the way home from visiting my Aunt in Nechells - she lived in a tower block - I remember the steep slide - but can't remember the name of park or road it was on.

Just curious :)
 
Hi Found the Nolan family on the 1881 census.


Dwelling: 4Ct H12 Lawley St
Census Place: Aston, Warwick, England
Source: FHL Film 1341723 PRO Ref RG11 Piece 3026 Folio 70 Page 4
Marr Age Sex Birthplace
Michael NOLAN M 49 M Ireland
Rel: Head
Occ: Wast Paper Dealer
Winifred NOLAN M 48 F Ireland
Rel: Wife
Mary Ann NOLAN U 26 F Bham, Warwick, England
Rel: Daur
Occ: Umbrella Worker
Catherine NOLAN U 25 F Bham, Warwick, England
Rel: Daur
Occ: Steel Pen Piercer
Daniel NOLAN U 24 M Bham, Warwick, England
Rel: Son
Occ: Gun Finisher
Bridget NOLAN U 21 F Bham, Warwick, England
Rel: Daur
Occ: Umberella Maker
Winifred NOLAN U 18 F Bham, Warwick, England
Rel: Daur
Occ: Button Cutter
John NOLAN U 17 M Bham, Warwick, England
Rel: Son
Occ: Brass Finisher
Michael J. NOLAN U 15 M Bham, Warwick, England
Rel: Son
Occ: Iron Molder
James NOLAN U 14 M Bham, Warwick, England
Rel: Son
Occ: Iron Tin Plate Worker
Martin NOLAN U 13 M Bham, Warwick, England
Rel: Son
Occ: Scholar
Thomas NOLAN U 11 M Bham, Warwick, England
Rel: Son
Occ: Scholar
Bella NOLAN U 8 F Bham, Warwick, England
Rel: Daur
Occ: Scholar
Annie NOLAN U 2 F Bham, Warwick, England
 
Thanks for that Nick I have a lot more info on Nolan which I will post a bit later but I feel the time is not right at the present
 
Came across the meaning of Spion Cop in a Newspaper dated Feb.10th 1900 so mystery solved
Spion in Dutch means View, Kop taken from the word Kopje
a mountain peak in one of the four well defined ranges or spurs of the great Drakensberg Mountains which spreading out from its base traverse Northern Natal
 
Crommie, are you able to expand on why he was 'unfit to plead' at his court mashall
 
Yes I can Frantic "Catch 22" If someone is declared insane they cannot " plead" as they have no say in the matter 
 
We really should get our own house 'in order' before we go clomping round the world sticking our collective noses into everyone elses business. That's the sort of thing that you expect to read about a so called "Third World" country, or dictatorship.
 
They would not publish it in the Regimental Magazine as the Queen was Colonel in chief of the Regiment
I also came across a 13 years old lad in the British army who was one of the first to be wounded in the Boer War and his age was known (now ya got me going I might put his photo up on the Boer War site )
 
Back
Top