• Welcome to this forum . We are a worldwide group with a common interest in Birmingham and its history. While here, please follow a few simple rules. We ask that you respect other members, thank those who have helped you and please keep your contributions on-topic with the thread.

    We do hope you enjoy your visit. BHF Admin Team

Battle of the Atlantic

  • Thread starter Thread starter Beryl M
  • Start date Start date
B

Beryl M

Guest
The Battle of the Atlantic

After reading the different accounts on the Battle of the Atlantic strong points are to be made as to why Britain and its Allies won.  We certainly could not have done it without the help of the U.S.  However, I believe this campaign was finally won by being one jump ahead of the Germans in inventions and technology...

Only a few hours after war was declared the British passenger ship liner Athenia was sunk in the Atlantic by a German U boat.  Children were on the ship on their way to the States and Canada for safety.  This is what convinced the Admiralty to set up convoy routes to help protect merchant ships.

The two main systems were the North-South convoys to the Mediterranean and West Africa and the East west convoys from North America to Great Britain.  The convoy system was considered to be the navys defense against Germanys Wolf Packs.  Destroyers and Corvettes protected merchant ships across three thousand miles of the Atlantic.  The Royal Navy escorts themselves were equipped with Asdic an echo sounding device for tracking U boats, but the problem was it only had a range of 1000 yards.  After that it was useless.

It was in April 1940 off the coast of Norway, the British destroyer Griffin received a signal that a ship in the area had been fired upon by a fishing trawler.  The Commander of the Griffin John Lee Barber spotted the fishing trawler flying the Dutch flag. A lot of men stood on the deck so it was decided they check it out.   It was a German trawler loaded with weapons.  A pistol was fired and the Germans began showing their secrets.  One of them pitched a bag of code books into the sea.  In a heroic act Gunner Florrie  Foord dived into the freezing water and grabbed the bag.   The Enigma material eventually found its way to the code breakers at Bletchley Park, which proved invaluable for breaking the German Naval code.

By June 1940 Germany was in control of the French Atlantic ports.  Hitler let loose his U boats in an aim to starve Great Britain and bring her to her knees.  They were found lurking in every sea lane attacking convoys on their way to Britain.

The worst attacks took place on the mid-Atlantic not covered by air escort called The Black Gap, escort aircraft carriers converted from merchant ships were being constructed in American and British shipyards.

In March 1942 the Germans were winning the war and producing submarines at a rate of 30 a month.  Also they had the ability to read coded messages from the Admiralty to the escorts, which made it possible to put U boat patrol lines across convoy routes.  These Wolf  Packs, as they were called, caused the Allies heavy losses, in one day alone a convoy lost as many as seven ships including the Canadian destroyer the Ottawa So many ships were lost that year a disaster for the Allies.

However, the turning point came in July 1942.  The R.A.F received Canadians long range Liberator aircraft which they needed to cover the Black Gap.  The United States were mass producing Liberty cargo ships  Aircraft carriers were built with flight decks that could hold up to 20 planes.  Radar equipped aircraft could take off the carriers and fill the Black Hole and attack German subs.

Finally, with new technologies most escorts and anti submarine aircraft received improved new ten centimeter radar equipment that could detect surface submarines at a long range at night, which had the biggest effect in the Atlantic Campaign.  Then Huff Duff (High Frequency Direction Finders) came along that were able to locate German subs by their radio traffic, this affected the German U boats when they were spread over a wide area they would need to use their radios more often to form their deadly Wolf Packs.  And of course the Allies now having Ultra Secret also had the ability to read the German Naval code.  Advances in technology and the breaking of German enigma codes guaranteed the Allies victory of the battle of the Atlantic and determined the world we live in today.

During a war that lasted six years so many battles were fought, far too many lives lost The losses suffered by the U Boat service was high and of 1158 Boats in service, 637 were lost and of those, 420 were lost in the Atlantic  There are thousands of German and Allied sailors buried in ships under the sea  40,000 men who served in  U Boats during the war and 20,000 of those did not return. Some 2000 Allied ships were sunk by U Boats 20,000 allied merchant seaman lost their lives and 6,000 aircrew of Allied Coastal Command also. Therefore we should respect the courage and sacrifice of the of all those who operated in a hostile environment

British Prime Minister Churchill afterwards said, the only thing that frightened me was the U boat peril.

Bibliography:
The Second World War by: John Keegan
The Most Secret war by: R.V Jones 
The Unruly Giant by: Norman Rose


Visit my website www.poetrydjour.com !!
 
HELLO BERYL M, I WAS VERY INTERESTED IN YOU ARTICLE REF. THE ATLANTIC CONYOYS. HAVE
READ QUITE A FEW TIMES THAT THE BATTLE OF THE ATLANTIC WAS OVER IN MAY 1943. MY BROTHER ALONG WITH 7 OTHER BRITISH SAILORS SERVED ON THE POLISH DESTROYER O.R.P. ORKAN
THEY WERE THERE FOR LIAISON WITH THE ROYAL NAVY, HE WAS A CODER. THE SHIP WAS TORPEDOED ON THE 8TH OCTOBER 1943. 178 MEN PERISHED, INCLUDING MY 20YEAR OLD BROTHER.
12 DAYS LATER AN AMERICAN AVENGER AIRCRAFT SIGHTED U.BOAT 378 THE ONE WHICH SANK THE "ORKAN" AND DESTROYED IT. I HAVE DONE A LOT OF RESEARCH INTO BOTH OF THE ACTIONS WITH SOME AMAZING RESULTS. GEFF
 
Geff I am so sorry about your 20 year old brother - so many men lost their lives all so very young on both sides - it's very sad

Firmly belief the breaking of codes was a shoe in for beating the Germans 

Geff I think you could write an article yourself - "Your brother's story" - Why not? very little is said about the navy - give it a go - Beryl
 
Beryl, Glad you got it sorted at last, glad you put this story up, as a lot of us lost folk that were neither in the army or air force, but in the merchant navy trying to do a very difficult job under terrible circumstances. My wifes Father was sunk three times in the Atlantic and all should have been given medals straight after the war, not years later.
 
Thanks Graham - Geff - I think between all your personal stories 2 chapters  each would make a book - what do you think????????  Yes I recall that about the medals not been given to years later - because they were civilians and to think at the time those in the Merchant Navy if they lost their ship and were picked up in a rubber life boat they became immediatety unemployed - how ridiculous
 
Beryl, not a lot of folk could understand how an aircraft could capture a submarine but it did happen in the Battle of the Atlantic
The aircraft of the coastal Command made 305 attacks on U-boats, nearly all of them in the course of the Battle of the Atlantic. They destroyed seventy-five enemy aircraft actually approaching to molest convoys, and drove off more than 500 of them, often heavily damaged.
But perhaps the most astonishing feat in the Battle of the Atlantic was the surrender of a German U-boat to Coastal Command aircraft. The U-boat was sighted by a Hudson and was forced to the surface by bombs. The crew then started to pour out of the conning tower, probably in an effort to man the guns, but the Hudson immediately attacked them with machine gun fire, and after four such attacks the U-boat crew surrendered, waving a white shirt and then a piece of white board to make their intentions clear, the Hudson continued to circle the U-boat with guns trained to resume the attack if necessary, while signals were sent off to base to bring other aircraft to the relief, and surface vessels to take charge of the U-boat
After three and a half hours a Catalina arrived to take over from the Hudson. She stood jailer in the air for seven and a half hours before the first naval vessel could get to the scene. In spite of a heavy gale that were running the Navy got the U-boat crew off and brought the U-boat intact into port Coastal Command aircraft kept up the air escort for a further forty hours until this was accomplished. This was the first under-water craft ever to have surrendered to an aircraft............absolutely astonishing
 
A few hours after war was declared the Germans sunk the defenceless "Athenia", with 1,400 Anglo American civilian passengers aboard, on September 4th 1939, they showed they meant to attack Britain's sea lanes even more ruthlessly than in the First World War. From the beginning it was apparent that the outcome of the war very largely depended upon Britain and America keeping control of the great Atlantic sea lane, and so in 1940 and 1941 the Battle of the Atlantic became one which had to be fought to a decision. If Britain lost it meant Britain would lose the war.
When Italy joined Germany 118 Italian submarines were added to Hitler's swarms of U-boats. And also the European coastline was available to the Germans for bases from which to launch their assault. In the July of 1940 313,000 tons of Allied shipping were sunk in the Atlantic. Long-range German bombers went out to support the attacking U-boats. As Nelson once sent the appeal.......... "Frigates, more frigates,"....... so British sailors now sent up the cry........... "Destroyers, more destroyers."... For in spite of our vast Navy insufficient escorting vessels existed to carry out the tasks which arose each month. Lurking U-boats were quick to exploit the opportunities which presented themselves when a convoy was sparsely guarded.
Then a magnificent gesture from the American people was announced by President Roosevelt.
Fifty over-age destroyers were to be exchanged with Britain for certain strategic bases........ which were to be leased to the United States..........We had no choice but to grant Roosevelt what he wanted but .......would he have helped if we had refused?
September and November 1940 were, nevertheless, black months at sea Each day the German Press and radio put out alarming stories of the tonnage sunk by their sea raiders. Their claims were much exaggerated and even absurd, but the real facts were grave enough 303,627 tons of British shipping had been sent to the bottom in November alone. This was a trifle better than the August figures which reached the total of 500,000 tons but the situation was still very grave.
This meant that ships were being destroyed faster than they could be built or repaired. For a long time this issue swayed in the balance. Hitler stated 1941 with a confident message that the Atlantic was to be closed to Britain. Wherever British ships cruise our U-boats will be sent against them until the hour they surrender. then the month of May brought the rising curve of German successes to its highest peak. And in spite of their immense casualties the men of the Merchant Navy held steady. Tramps still plodded, back and forward across the Atlantic, oil tankers and merchant vessels carrying countless varieties of food and munitions, machinery and raw materials braved the sudden encounter with the underwater menace that cost scores of good ships and thousands of brave men. "Arandora Star", "Rawalpindi"," Lustrous", "Marathon", "British Strength", "Athelfoam", "Mangkai", "Demeterton", "Silverfir", "Sardinian Prince", "Empress of Britain", "Dunbar Castle", "Rangitane", "Jervis Bay", "Laurentic", "Simon Bolivar" these are but a few of names as well as hundreds more that have an honoured place in the list.
Slowly Long range Catalina aircraft of Coastal Command, fast armed escort vessels, improved apparatus for detecting the U-boat, and the increased tempo of shipbuilding all contributed towards bringing the danger under control, but the process was slow, and only made possible by the bravery of the Merchant Navy.
In fact the Battle of the Atlantic, although lulls occurred while the U-boats were refitted, was the longest battle of the war. Improvements in technique by the hunters were met by fresh devices invented by the hunted. Only unceasing vigilance and devotion to duty made the invasion of Germany possible in the face of determined efforts by the enemy to sink supplies being sent by sea to Britain. We have a lot to thank the Merchant Navy for, without them Britain would have sunk
 
The battle of the Atlantic was the longest continuous battle of World War 11. It began when war was declared in 1939 and ended in May 1945. For the merchant seamen the treacherous voyages began on the east coast of Canada or the United States under escort of available RCN ships and later the Canadian Royal Air Force. The original route across the North Atlantic had the RCN turn around in Iceland. In early 1942 their eastern terminus became Londonderry, Northern Ireland. This became the famed Newfie Derry run. Warships stationed in St John’s would come out to meet the ocean going convoys and take over escort across the ocean until the British patrols met them north of Ireland. After a layover in Londonderry, the ships would then escort a returning convoy.

For the navy and air force it was not a war of objectives but a completely defensive battle as they constantly patrolled for the dreaded U-Boats that sometimes wandered in packs and sometimes wandered alone in stealth looking for the opportunity to strike. Feared most of all by the sailors was a large mid ocean area known as the Black Gap This was where ships were on their own out of the range of aircraft cover.

The Royal Canadian Navy lost 28 ships and approximately 2,000 men during World War 11. This total covers many theatres but most of these men fought and died in the Battle of the Atlantic. (Preserving the Atlantic Lifeline May/June) Canada’s merchant Navy suffered tremendous loss. Indeed 73 ships that flew Canada’s Red Ensign were sunk and more than 2,000 seamen died. Most of those who died at sea have no headstone to mark their passing. It is so sad the names of so many are marked only with an inscription on a memorial.

And yet perhaps fitting that sea, which was their field of battle for so many, also became the cemetery!
 
BerylM.
I enjoyed reading your posting on the Merchant Navy very Much, I had the priviledge to be in contact with both Canadian and British Veterns of the Merchant Navy, whose contributions helped me with a presentation I needed for My war Studies course at Birmingham University.
Despite all they went through and some of the horrors they saw, they still had a sense of humour,I had many a laugh on receiving e-mails from them.
THe saddest thing was keeping up withe the convoys, they sometimes could not pick up suvivours of ships in the convoy sunk by U.boats.
maggie
 
ppp.jpeg


This was on the 'LETTERS' page in todays Birmingham Mail, it follows one or two from last week about the same subject and they made me think of my old friend who now lives in S. Wales. I have known Bob for 50 years and have never heard complain about anything. He was on the North Atlantic convoys as a ships engineer so he was below decks almost all the time. He rarely speaks about the war and the following is what I have pieced together over the years. Two of the ships he was on were sunk so he lost a number of friends and after the second sinking they were due out on HMS Trinidad. However the day before setting sail Bob was taken off the Trinidad and put on a landing craft of some sort taking two tanks and crews as part of an invasion. All his old crew-mates left port aboard the Trinidad and a couple of days later it was sunk with almost all hands lost at sea. Bobs attitude has always been that this, and worse happened to many others and his sympathy was always for those who froze in the cold water before they could be rescued. Bob is and always has been a true gent and it is because of horrific stories like this that I always pay my respects to The British Legion and attend either a service or a memorial each year. Wooton Bassett was a rtather moving experience . Bob now has some sort of dementia and can not get out on his own and that is why I drive down to Llanelli to see him about six times a year between spring and autumn.
stitcher.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Back
Top