Eddie...the answer to the question is 'yes' Villa did beat a German Select X1 not once but twice on a three-match tour to Germany in May 1938 and there's a cracking true story to it. For the first match, in Berlin, there was a 70,000 crowd on a sizzling hot day, and the Villa players were required, by German officials and the British Embassy diplomats to give the German salute before the kick-off. In the dressing room before the kick-off the Villa lads went potty but a week earlier an England team had played there and had reluctantly given way to avoid an international incident with war imminent. However Villa declined and then went out and beat a virtual international line-up on the field. The German High Command was not at all happy about the refusal to do the Heil Hitler bit, so for the next match, in Stuttgart, the British Ambassador almost begged the Villa to oblige this time to try an avoid Europe being plunged into WW2. Still it was 'no way' among the Villa lads but they cooked up a cunning ploy. As a 'compromise' (described by one of the players, Eric Houghton, later) they would mix in a good old fashioned British two-fingered salute and that's what they did. The German crowd, believing that the English had been forced to submit, gave a huge round of applause. Little did they realise that Villa were actually saying: 'Not on your Nellie, Mr. Hitler...Up yours.....' They then went out and won again but later, sadly lost the third match of the tour. By then, though, they had illustrated firmly that Brits don't bow at the knee that easily....Cheers.... Dennis S