In the 1891 Census I've searched the whole of Hurst Street, which is numbered consecutively, and all in the Parish of St Jude, and whilst there are half a dozen pubs, none incorporate the letters S & M in their names. Lots of courts of houses and a People's Hall. So unless it was an organisation which met in the People's Hall, or an unnamed lock-up business, I'm stumped as my subscription to Midlands Historical Data & the trade directories has expired.
Chris, would it be likely the Small Heath Angling Club met in the People's Hall? And the second letter is definitely an M.
I think we need access to a trade directory.......
Maurice