• Welcome to this forum . We are a worldwide group with a common interest in Birmingham and its history. While here, please follow a few simple rules. We ask that you respect other members, thank those who have helped you and please keep your contributions on-topic with the thread.

    We do hope you enjoy your visit. BHF Admin Team

William Hutton’s houses in High Street

Vivienne14

Kentish Brummie Moderator
Staff member
Over time William Hutton had several premises in High Street, Birmingham (as well as homes he built at Bennett’s Hill House and Red House in Washwood Heath). The buildings in High Street were demolished a long time ago, but these notes I’ve drawn together may give readers a snapshot of Hutton’s surroundings in the 1770s.


High Street house dated 1567 - 1776

In the 1770s Hutton was living in an old house (actually two old houses of wood and plaster) number 90, near the junction of New St and High St. The entrance to New St from High St was, at the time, through a gateway under Hutton’s dining room. This building was demolished in 1776 because it interfered with traffic. By then it had been there for 208 years - built in 1567. (Source: Wm Hutton’s History of Birmingham)

Hutton thought the house foundations had originally been built with stones from the old Priory. It had used about 30 wagons of stone. Some of the Priory stones were highly finished pieces from porticos, windows, arches, some fluted, some ciphered, some ornamented.(Source: Wm Hutton’s History of Birmingham).

High Street house(s) 1775

His next venture was also located near the junction with New Street, building 3 houses numbered 24, 25 and 26 High Street. (Source: Catherine Hutton’s letter to Mrs Coltman 27/5/1775) One was used as his town residence and a paper warehouse for the Hutton business.

Some of the old Priory stones from the earlier house were re-used by Hutton in a fireplace in an under kitchen, the stones framing the sides of the fireplace in the front cellar.

Reconstruction in 1895 by John Sumner, Draper
The premises underwent reconstruction in 1895 for occupation by Mr John Sumner & Sons (having previously been at Bull Street, the move to High Street made necessary by the railway tunnel works). This reconstruction revealed several features from Hutton’s time including:

- one Priory stone was used as a decorative rather than functional piece by Mr Sumner; a red Hamstead sandstone stone which was inserted as a bracket in his office. It’s believed this was a rare piece of the old Priory

- a huge, whitewashed, oak beam, 16” square and 10’ 6” long. It was inscribed “1567” and “1775” - the dates of the older Hutton house and his second house. Mr Sumner re-used this beam over a doorway and also inscribed it with “1895 J S & S”.

- on the front of an alcove in Hutton’s bedroom was a tablet bearing his coat of arms. This was removed with difficulty by Mr Sumner. It was restored, particularly the bucks heads which had been chiselled off !

- a highly varnished door with painted shells and musical instruments.

- the reconstructed house was to be called “Hutton House”. The freehold remained with the Hutton family.

A publication “Birmingham faces and places, June 1889” describes some other features dating back to Hutton:

- a Georgian mantelpiece and fire grate of wood and gesso work in the style of Chippendale, with lateral supports of flouted columns with Corinthian capitals. These displayed the Hutton family arms on a shield with three buck’s heads. Each side of this were lyres with festoons of flowers. Panels over the columns had the crests of the Hutton’s; a coronet pierced with three arrows. The whole was supposed to have been removed to the Art Gallery. It’s thought the fireplace may have originally been installed following the damage from the 1791 Riots.

- an old black staircase with an inlaid Chippendale balustrade.

- a backroom fireplace with delicately modelled figures.

- a richly moulded ceiling and cornice above the main staircase pierced by a large oval skylight of 20 panes radiating from the centre. Mouldings were in the Adam or Chippendale style, featuring vases, festoons, egg patterns and lions heads. This had all been overloaded with whitewash.

As a reminder, today there is a Blue Plaque on the Waterstone’s building indicating Hutton lived in buildings on the site from 1772 until 1791.

Be good to see any drawings of the buildings mentioned if they exist. And does anyone know if the Georgian mantelpiece and fire grate made it into the Art Gallery Collection ?

Viv.
 
Last edited:
For information. Here is where no 90 High st was in mid 1880s. Th position of the buildings does not allow us to say exactly where the original Hutton house was, as the configuration of the earlier buildings was somewhat different, and only smaller scale maps are extant, but it would apparently be in approximately the same position

map c1889 showing  position of 90 high st.jpg
 
Thanks Mike. And presumably the course of the road was slightly altered (widened?) when the building was demolished in 1776 as it ”interfered with traffic”. Viv.
 
Yes Viv. There was a big lump that extended into theme road, and the shape of the junction was different. That is why I commented that we cannot be sure exactly where the building was
 
mike do you know the name of the pub next to huttons house on the high st...closest pic i have is of the swan hotel which was behind huttons house


City High St Swan Hotel.JPG
 
Last edited:
Hopefully Mike can tell us Lyn. I wondered if it was the Hen & Chickens, but not sure. As Mike says that junction changed for road improvements in 1770s

This is a c1780 view looking down New Street towards High Street (High Town). Hen and Chickens to the right (“Hotel”).

A wild card, but could the building at the end of New Street (extreme left), be one of Hutton’s later houses (built 1775/6) - either #24, #25 or #26 High Street ? It has retail premises at ground floor level. We know that Hutton also had a warehouse for his paper stores (ransacked during the 1791 riots). Viv.

41481224-C6B4-4656-B3A4-7AE1D4151D00.jpeg
 
Last edited:
thanks viv...i was not sure if it was stevens bar on the corner cant be certain which corner of the high st that was
 
thanks viv..i was just curious...just read that in 1751 hutton rented a shop at no 6 bull st for a shilling a week

lyn
 
Last edited:
Oops typo Lyn - 1751 ! It was I believe, half a shop. Started the paper business there before he moved to High Street. Viv.
 
Last edited:
Copying Mike’s 1950s map from the Stevens Bar thread to here as it shows where #24, 25 and 26 High Street were opposite Stevens Bar corner. Viv.

736C4790-096E-472A-AA11-396E239411F9.jpeg
 
The business was still going in 1842. Hutton’s great nephew S Hutton carried it on until 1842 when S Hutton retired, Viv.

71638545-C681-4BF6-AB59-7397CF2212C4.jpeg
 
The Times Furnishing Building/Waterstones now stands on the site of Hutton's High Street premises. There’s a blue plaque fixed to Waterstones. It was built in 1936. I doubt the Hutton buildings were still there until that time as the old buildings next door were demolished to make way for the Co-op in 1913. The Co-op subsequently suffered WW2 damage in the photo below. Viv.

2600D803-D9A4-4AEB-BBB7-EDD3AC3C87B2.jpeg
 
so very little chance of a photo or drawing of his house on the high st...just re reading vivs post 1 he also had properties at 24.25 and 26 high st so was there a re numbering or was no 90 a completely different building...bit confused at the min nothing unusual for me ..this very observant man has grabbed my attention again...we can never learn enough:D thanks jan going to look at that link now

lyn
 
Lyn. Number 90 was Hutton’s first High Street address until 1775/6. He then moved across the road when he built 24, 25 and 26 High Street. They’re different locations, the early one on one side, the later one(s) on the TimesWaterstones Building site. Viv.
 
Very confusing. Hutton certainly had a thing about property. Not only did he have the other ‘country’ residences (Washwood Heath) but I’ve seen he had a place in Erdington too. Viv.
 
i agree viv...he was certainly a brilliant historian although given the time of his observations i know that just like artists we have to take some things with a pinch of salt (no camera in those days )...accuracy is not always spot on...however i admire him greatly

lyn
 
Viv
Hopefully Mike can tell us Lyn. I wondered if it was the Hen & Chickens, but not sure. As Mike says that junction changed for road improvements in 1770s

This is a c1780 view looking down New Street towards High Street (High Town). Hen and Chickens to the right (“Hotel”).

A wild card, but could the building at the end of New Street (extreme left), be one of Hutton’s later houses (built 1775/6) - either #24, #25 or #26 High Street ? It has retail premises at ground floor level. We know that Hutton also had a warehouse for his paper stores (ransacked during the 1791 riots). Viv.

View attachment 149048

Lyn. Yes it was the Swan commercial Hotel, listed at 138 New St, and run in the 1880s by Mrs Sarah Street.

If huttons house was where the Times building was then
 
Although Lyn I do think there’s a good chance of the house furthest left in pic #7 has a good chance of being Hutton’s second (1775/6) house (#24, 25 and/or #26 High Street). It must be very, very close when you look at the position of the Times Furnishing/Waterstones Building. Viv.
 
Yes Viv, agree that is very possible. It would be the building marked in black on the c1750 map below

map c 1750 with possible hutton house.jpg

EDIT.Sorry . The black building might have been the earlier house, not the later
 
Last edited:
The house that Hutton built in High Street in 1775/6. This would have been the one on the site of the Times Furnishing/Waterstone’s Building. It seems it was demolished in 1928, the photo probably captured it just before demolition, Viv.

2CBE9DEB-4264-4815-B9AD-A57F2C1AA1C1.jpeg
 
Last edited:
In a document called “Memorandums from memory all trifles and of ancient date” (starting 9/3/1796) William Hutton retrospectively recorded this information about his High Street premises. Viv.

2428AA97-649C-498A-9D47-4E443F30BA71.jpeg
 
Over time William Hutton had several premises in High Street, Birmingham (as well as homes he built at Bennett’s Hill House and Red House in Washwood Heath). The buildings in High Street were demolished a long time ago, but these notes I’ve drawn together may give readers a snapshot of Hutton’s surroundings in the 1770s.


High Street house dated 1567 - 1776

In the 1770s Hutton was living in an old house (actually two old houses of wood and plaster) number 90, near the junction of New St and High St. The entrance to New St from High St was, at the time, through a gateway under Hutton’s dining room. This building was demolished in 1776 because it interfered with traffic. By then it had been there for 208 years - built in 1567. (Source: Wm Hutton’s History of Birmingham)

Hutton thought the house foundations had originally been built with stones from the old Priory. It had used about 30 wagons of stone. Some of the Priory stones were highly finished pieces from porticos, windows, arches, some fluted, some ciphered, some ornamented.(Source: Wm Hutton’s History of Birmingham).

High Street house(s) 1775

His next venture was also located near the junction with New Street, building 3 houses numbered 24, 25 and 26 High Street. (Source: Catherine Hutton’s letter to Mrs Coltman 27/5/1775) One was used as his town residence and a paper warehouse for the Hutton business.

Some of the old Priory stones from the earlier house were re-used by Hutton in a fireplace in an under kitchen, the stones framing the sides of the fireplace in the front cellar.

Reconstruction in 1895 by John Sumner, Draper
The premises underwent reconstruction in 1895 for occupation by Mr John Sumner & Sons (having previously been at Bull Street, the move to High Street made necessary by the railway tunnel works). This reconstruction revealed several features from Hutton’s time including:

- one Priory stone was used as a decorative rather than functional piece by Mr Sumner; a red Hamstead sandstone stone which was inserted as a bracket in his office. It’s believed this was a rare piece of the old Priory

- a huge, whitewashed, oak beam, 16” square and 10’ 6” long. It was inscribed “1567” and “1775” - the dates of the older Hutton house and his second house. Mr Sumner re-used this beam over a doorway and also inscribed it with “1895 J S & S”.

- on the front of an alcove in Hutton’s bedroom was a tablet bearing his coat of arms. This was removed with difficulty by Mr Sumner. It was restored, particularly the bucks heads which had been chiselled off !

- a highly varnished door with painted shells and musical instruments.

- the reconstructed house was to be called “Hutton House”. The freehold remained with the Hutton family.

A publication “Birmingham faces and places, June 1889” describes some other features dating back to Hutton:

- a Georgian mantelpiece and fire grate of wood and gesso work in the style of Chippendale, with lateral supports of flouted columns with Corinthian capitals. These displayed the Hutton family arms on a shield with three buck’s heads. Each side of this were lyres with festoons of flowers. Panels over the columns had the crests of the Hutton’s; a coronet pierced with three arrows. The whole was supposed to have been removed to the Art Gallery. It’s thought the fireplace may have originally been installed following the damage from the 1791 Riots.

- an old black staircase with an inlaid Chippendale balustrade.

- a backroom fireplace with delicately modelled figures.

- a richly moulded ceiling and cornice above the main staircase pierced by a large oval skylight of 20 panes radiating from the centre. Mouldings were in the Adam or Chippendale style, featuring vases, festoons, egg patterns and lions heads. This had all been overloaded with whitewash.

As a reminder, today there is a Blue Plaque on the Waterstone’s building indicating Hutton lived in buildings on the site from 1772 until 1791.

Be good to see any drawings of the buildings mentioned if they exist. And does anyone know if the Georgian mantelpiece and fire grate made it into the Art Gallery Collection ?

Viv.

The complete article from Birmingham Faces and Places is attached, together with a photo of a fireplace (chimneypiece) from his building are below:

fireplace from huttons paper warehouseA.jpgHuttons paper warehouse.jpg
 
A great piece Mike, thanks. Good to see the fireplace. And I like the business card for Samuel Hutton. A wealth of history uncovered - would have been wonderful to have been there to uncover it. The business was put up for sale by Samuel in 1842. If the building remained until 1928 hopefully more of the Hutton’s artifacts were removed before demolition. Viv.
 
Last edited:
There are many similarities between the two buildings in the top 1780 drawing and the 1928 photo. The ground floor shop is changed but I think above that level there’s a match. Although there are only three columns of windows in the top 1780s drawing, to be symmetrical it can be seen it would have had 4 columns of windows. Viv.

3E24CC7A-D0E5-46DB-8DE9-0DE989891660.jpeg
 
Back
Top